Growwer
SEO

How to choose a good link building agency (based on our experience)

Written by Growwer · · Updated on

How to choose a good link building agency (based on our experience)

Choosing a link building agency can make the difference between climbing the rankings in Google or getting stuck behind the competition. At Growwer, we have spent years building quality links, and we know firsthand what makes an agency truly good.

In this guide, we share the essentials so you can make an informed, strategic decision. If you are thinking about outsourcing the link building of your project, this is for you.

Office building labelled Link Building illustrating how to choose a link building agency

Link building is one of the most powerful strategies in off-page SEO. With relevant, quality links, you can increase your domain authority, improve your rankings and attract qualified traffic.

But not all links are worth the same. And not all agencies work with the same ethics, experience or methodology.

A bad choice can lead to:

  • Toxic links that get your website penalized.
  • Inflated or fake results.
  • Budget lost with no return.

That is why choosing well is not optional: it is a strategic investment. Taking the time to compare, analyze and ask questions is essential if you want the money you invest in SEO to actually work.

Define your goals before hiring an agency

Before looking for an agency, the first thing we need to be clear about is what we want to achieve with link building. Defining goals not only helps you filter agencies, it also lets you build a coherent strategy from the start.

For example:

  • If your goal is to improve rankings, the strategy will focus on specific keywords and links in niche media outlets.
  • If you need traffic, the priority will be exposure in media outlets with a good audience.
  • If you are after authority, the work will focus on media outlets with high metrics such as DR, DA or TF.

At Growwer, we always ask for this information first. It is the starting point to make sure every link building action makes sense and is aligned with the business goals.

Growwer managed campaigns: strategy, media chosen by budget and orders run until published

Today, good link building agencies share a set of key traits. Here we explain the most important ones in more detail so you know what to ask and what to evaluate.

A clear methodology and strategy

A serious agency does not improvise. It should have a structured methodology, from the initial analysis to tracking the results. This includes:

  • Selecting relevant media outlets.
  • Defining anchor texts.
  • Balancing the link profile.
  • A publishing calendar.

It should also be able to explain this methodology in simple terms and adapt it to your specific needs.

Experience in your industry

Working with an agency that understands your niche is a huge plus. Getting links for a fashion e-commerce store is not the same as getting them for a B2B SaaS. Every industry has its own particularities and specialized media outlets.

At Growwer, for example, we have categories and industry filters, which let us identify specific opportunities for each client.

Companies that trust Growwer: Amazon, Heineken, Binance, Mercado Libre, eDreams and Mail Boxes Etc

Quality over quantity

Effective link building is not about “how many” links, but which ones. A single link in a quality media outlet can have more impact than 50 on irrelevant websites. It is vital to prioritize:

  • Real media outlets with organic traffic.
  • Well-written, contextualized content.
  • Topical relevance.
35,649 Growwer media outlets, including Forbes, The Times, El País and Marca

Transparent communication

A good agency should give you full visibility into what it is doing. That includes:

  • A list of media outlets before or after publishing.
  • Metrics for the links obtained.
  • Regular reports with results and progress.

Tools and technology (AI included)

In 2025, many agencies already use automation and artificial intelligence to work more efficiently. This makes it possible to:

  • Spot opportunities faster.
  • Optimize media selection.
  • Automate part of the outreach and reporting.

Of course, this must be combined with human expertise to keep the quality of the process.

Red flags: how to spot a bad agency

Some link building agencies rely on unethical or ineffective practices. These are some of the signs that should make you think twice:

  • They promise “100 links in a week”.
  • They do not show examples or give you references.
  • They use PBNs (private blog networks) without telling you.
  • They offer suspiciously low prices.

Our advice: if something sounds too good to be true, it probably is.

A professional agency stands out for three things: judgment, a strategic approach and measurable results.

In our case, these are some of the practices we consider essential and apply to every project:

  • Organic, editorial links.
  • Direct relationships with real media outlets and blogs.
  • Ongoing advice.
  • Editorial selection of content.

This not only improves SEO, it also adds brand value and credibility.

At Growwer, we do not just offer links. We design comprehensive strategies tailored to the client's industry, goals and SEO maturity. Our approach is based on:

  • Access to 35,000+ media outlets with topic categories.
  • A tool to manage the whole process.
  • Clear, measurable reports.
  • Strategic support.

We work to turn every link into a real growth opportunity.

How much should I pay for a good link?

It depends on the media outlet, its traffic and its authority. The key is the value it brings, not the unit price.

How long does it take to see the effect of link building?

Usually between 2 and 4 months, although it can vary depending on the industry and the competition.

Can I review the links before they are published?

It depends on the agency. At Growwer, we offer a prior review or a custom selection of media outlets.

Do I only need link building, or on-page SEO as well?

It depends on where you are now. A complete strategy always performs better, but you can start with the external pillar if you already have a solid internal foundation.

Hiring a link building agency is not a minor decision. Choosing well can save you months (and thousands of euros) on strategies that do not work.

Our advice from Growwer: do your research, compare and choose with a long-term view. Do not buy links, build authority.

And if you want to work with an agency that:

  • Puts quality before quantity,
  • Adapts to your industry and goals,
  • And gives you real, measurable results…

We are here to help.

Get links and mentions in more than 40,000 media

Register for free and receive proposals from media related to your project in minutes.

These companies already trust Growwer